Integrated Human Practice
Overview
In our project, integrated human practices play an significant part in digging deeper into the issue we concerned and achieving our economically beneficial and eco-friendly goal.
After various interviews, we realize there exists a problem in China that a few people know little about the cruel damage of heavy metals. Thus, how to build an both educational and sobering environment is also what we aim to figure out in our human practices.
Our product is an E. coli biosensor called “Silence” which contained two plasmids: one could produce a colored feruloyl esterase upon detecting the element cadmium and zinc; the other one can produce green fluorescent protein when the arsenic is detected. In short, our product could be the detector by showing different colors when distinguishing different heavy elements. Besides, our product has the advantage of being cheaper and more portable. What’s more, we hope this product can be thereby offered to fishery practitioners and people who share the same concerns about water pollution.
Our brainstorm map regarding Integrated Human Practice is shown below:
Questionnaire Survey
A product needs to be recognized by the market to be a good product, and we need to get more professional insights and social surveys to better understand the market and then adjust our product to meet the need. In order to understand the public's awareness of heavy metal pollution, we released an anonymous questionnaire on WeChat and invited people to complete this survey.
So far, our received 1060 samples. Most of our respondents were teenagers and middle-aged people, and the majority lives in the urban area.
According to the statistics, there is only 3% of respondents who claimed they know about the metal pollution well, but more than 70% admitted they knew few, even not at all. Then in regards to their attention to heavy metals, more than the half of the respondents felt that they didn’t pay enough attention to heavy metals. By spreading this questionnaire, we were also calling for more social attention to this topic, this issue.
To further investigating the awareness of the public thinking of the metal pollution and meantime triggering the sense of the respondents to pay more attention to the heavy metal pollution, we were asking the respondent how they think of the heavy metal pollution affecting our daily life. As seen in the below result, people do have a rough awareness about how the heavy metal pollution may do harm to our daily life even our physical health. But combining with their previous answers, we could indicate that they didn’t receive related scientific education or delicate explanation so that they didn’t possess a clear awareness of the heavy metal pollution and its impact. Besides, they were not quite sure how the heavy metal pollution will challenge the society safety. Therefore, we realize that the public education on heavy metal pollution is necessary.
In order to decide the channel for our future education activities, we also asked where they gain information about heavy metal pollution. During these 1060 completed questionnaires, we can obvious see that News Report is the most common used channel people gather information about heavy metal pollution, then TV, short videos, paper materials and WeChat Official Account. For most public, they might not take the initiative to search or learn heavy metal pollution until there comes some related news. Therefore, we decided to take the responsibility to spread information about heavy metal pollution to raise the public’ attention on this issue and also we will carry out the education activities through some short videos, WeChat Official Account and some lectures.
In this online survey, we also did some market research for our future products, the detector of heavy metal elements. According to our survey, there were 141 respondents who claimed they have bought products which could be used to detect heavy metals and 51.68% of these 141 respondents bought from supermarket and 30.2% bought from online stores. These information could be our reference for future business plan.
Since everyone could be our potential customers, so we sought their opinions about the expectation on our product, the heavy metal detector. As seen in figure 7, the most concerning factor about the detector product is its performance, so how to improve the performance, how to optimize the design shall be the top priority of our project. Then the safety, which is also what we concern about. Besides these, our potential customers still care about the price , the portability and the operation since everyone would like this detector be cheap, handy and easy to operate.
Overall, through this online survey, it is clear that people are not quite aware of the exact dangers of the heavy metal pollution and even if they might have a rough sense, they do not pay enough attention to them. In recent years, the government has strongly supported the development of regulations regarding the prevention and treatment of heavy metals. In response to the above, we believe that there is a need to increase awareness of heavy metals so that people can understand the advantages and dangers. Therefore, the related scientific education is necessary. Besides, Many people did not buy heavy metal testing instruments probably because of the performance, the portability and the price, our target final product might meet their need.
Experts’ Interview
Stage 1. Current solutions and our competitiveness
We had an interview with Professor Huimei Shan from College of Environmental Science and Engineering, Guilin University of Technology, who is an expert in groundwater pollution and prevention.
● Part 1.1 Diversity of heavy metals
We know that heavy metals are very common in our life nowadays, different types of heavy metals will certainly have different levels of pollution. Professor Shan explaint it this way:
Soil heavy metals refer to metals with a density greater than 4.5g/cm3, mainly including cadmium (Cd), mercury (Hg), arsenic (As), chromium (Cr), copper (Cu), nickel (Ni), zinc (Zn), etc. YANG et al. (2018) collected and detected heavy metal content in 1 041 agricultural lands and 402 industrial lands in China, and found that heavy metal pollution in soil in China was very serious and widespread, especially cadmium, lead and arsenic.
● Part 1.2 How to detect heavy metals
We wanted to learn the current detection methods to detect or deal with heavy metals so that we can study from them. Professor Shan said there were mainly 2 methods.
Dry digestion method
Using high temperature to make organic matter ash, and then through solvent extraction, to eliminate other ion interference effects. When using the dry digestion method for sample processing, reagent consumption is less, organic matter decomposition is complete, and multiple samples can be processed at the same time. However, the dry digestion method takes longer than other methods, and due to the absorption effect of crucible heating on the measured components, the recovery of heavy metals is low, which affects the accuracy of the determination results.
Wet digestion method
The organic compounds in the samples were digested by concentrated nitric acid, potassium permanganate, hydrogen peroxide and other acid solvents and oxidants. Compared with the single acid digestion sample, the mixed acid digestion sample has less volatilization loss, a higher recovery rate and a more thorough decomposition. However, the reagent dosage is large and the use of strong acid and strong oxidant may lead to harmful gases.
● Part 1.3 Social Concerns
Q: What are the possible obstacles/difficulties in dealing with environmental pollution at present?
A: The main heavy metal pollution in different regions is different because of the different pollution
routes of pollution sources. Many methods of dealing with environmental pollution have limitations. For
example, some methods are good at removing arsenic, but weak at removing other heavy metals.
Q:What is the difference between heavy metal pollution and other pollution? Source, nature, hazard?
A: Heavy metal pollution is mainly caused by mining and sewage irrigation from industrial production.
This
pollution does harm to human bodies, even it will be carcinogenic.
Q: Is there any way to raise public awareness of environmental protection?
A: Science popularization, like animation, cartoons, film and television and other methods. There are
many
international films about environmental protection, but relatively few domestic films.
Stage 2. Product implementation and development
We also managed to interview with Dr. Shiyuan Li, Cathy Fortune Capital Investment Synthetic Biology Line Research Business Director, who provided many great advice on how to implement our final products.
● Part 2.1 Biological expression system construction
Q: When you have a project concept, how to build a corresponding biological expression system? What
aspects should we pay special attention to when constructing an expression system?
A: First, three aspects should be considered: the chassis of expression should be selected, which system
should be selected, whether the microorganism is safe, the difficulty of operation, the effect of
expression should be excellent, and the source of the selected microorganism.
● Part 2.2 Final product design
Q: What aspects should be considered in advance from the initial product to the final product?
A: There are 3 major aspects.
Consider or understand whether the product is needed in the real world, such as the target group (farmers, government agencies, people in the home, different groups of people with different goals), the market, who will buy it, and the user group. Second, the market situation, the advantages and disadvantages of similar products and their own products focus on testing which products are sold, and how big the market is, how many annual sales, how many annual interest rates, the price. Third, assuming that the product has advantages, then how to replace our products, how to publicize the advantages of our products, promote to the market.
Fluorescent protein itself is not easy to distinguish its luminous intensity. If our live bacterial expression has the need to detect different concentrations, what methods can be used to quantify (or distinguish different levels of) concentration expression? Our idea is: is it possible to design a set of color cards to correspond to the fluorescence expression of different colors, so as to express the concentration through different colors?
It is better to quantify, which will be more difficult because there are many considerations. The very standardized fixed amount, reaction time and temperature, microbial state time, and the product form of freeze-dried powder should be fixed. The higher expression will be faster, and cheaper is the color card. The fluorescence detector will be more accurate, mainly depending on the demand. If it is a rural site, the fluorescence detector will be better, because it will always be used.
Q: The product we made this time needs to be expressed by living bacteria. In the case of high
requirements for bacterial activity, what are the possible solutions to ensure the convenience of the
product. at present, our idea is to freeze-dried bacteria. If low temperature is required, how to ensure
the reaction expression efficiency of bacteria?
A: Live bacteria must be freeze-dried. Now engineering bacteria are used for testing, which is a rare
thing. Except for testing, engineering bacteria are mainly medical, but they are also in the clinical
stage. For safety and regulatory regard, we may have to deal with the government, because the use of
engineering bacteria is still limited and regulated by policies. Freeze drying doesn’t mean completely
stable, it varies by species, protective agents, temperatures, etc. It is quite complex. We can look at
the acellular system, which is very similar to active dry yeast, seeming dead, but still working
like a
live bacterium. Without the shell of the cell, the contents are still functioning and safer.
Stage 3. Experiment Optimization Consulting
In order to optimize our experiment design, we had a virtual interview with Professor Wen Zhiqiang from the School of Food and Pharmaceutical Engineering, Nanjing Normal University, PhD. from Zhejiang University. In this interview, Prof. Wen introduced some current biosensor design to us, also provided some technical advice on the experimental design and optimization.
● Part 3.1 Determined factors
Q: What factors determine the expression of signals and sensing sequences in the design of biosensors?
A: In general, the expression signal is mainly determined by the object you detect. For example, the
object
you detect is colored. For example, there is a period of green algae outbreak in Taihu Lake, and you
need
to check whether the water in Taihu Lake is polluted by this heavy metal. Well, you might want to
consider
using globin. Or use this so-called yellow fluorescent protein. In general, it's mainly because there
are
so many signals that you can choose from.What it does is it takes this so-called heavy metal ion to get
into the active center of this protein, and then this protein it recognizes this particular sensing
sequence that we have. In fact, the process of our improvement is a process of protein recognition of
DV,
or recognition of I, in general, you basically have what is called protein determination, which is
determined by what you detect, so in other words these two factors are summed up.
Q: If the expression of biological inductors has cross-influence factors, let's say a lot of colors are
mixed together, what method will we use to adjust?
A: This is actually one of the biggest problems that we often have when we're doing this so-called
biosensor. I wanted to express this green fluorescent protein, but actually, your expression of this
protein is not in a vacuum, it's in an aqueous solution of your test sample. The background of it. It's
just a little bit yellowish, even if it's a little bit cloudy. Maybe sometimes it's not easy to get it
out
of the background.
My suggestion, you need something called a double base color. I used a red and I also used a blue, and you know red, yellow, and blue, and there's a lot of variations of the colors. Let's say you take that red and you take that yellow, and these are two colors cross over and it shows up as the new color, and you know that you can adjust the intensity of these two different fluorescent proteins, and it shows up as a new color. Until you have this new color that will make a significant difference from your base color. You have to tune it up some other way, remotely, to get it out.
● Part 3.2 Our challenge and improvement advice
Q: What we want to do is that the test box is a biological test paper, but we can only do qualitative
not
quantitative. And do you have any solutions or suggestions?
A: It should be said that most of test papers, are qualitative. This is a recognized problem in the
industry, including our nucleic acid test strips. But if you're willing to take more time and pay more
money on this development, and someone is willing to buy it, it might be achievable. Usually it has a
linear growth up to a certain range. When the concentration of heavy metals is relatively low, let's say
you make a co-factor, or you make the central structure of a protein an accessory muscle. The more
proteins that are activated, the more it recognizes this sensibility, and then, the more intense the
fluorescent protein will be expressed. It's a linear growth process. But when you overload the extra
heavy
metal elements, the fluorescent protein might show no difference or be gone since it reaches the
inflection point, the flat. That's why all of our test strips have effective test range.
In addition, in the real world, you might need an additional part - the activated charcoal. It can help you adsorb those confusing colors of the water sample before we take the heavy metal detection. You can attach this part to your detector and make it small, simple and easy to handle.
● Part 3.3 Operation concerns
Q: After the test paper is used for detection, how to deal with it, will there be some heavy metal residue
on it?
A: Usually the water sample you use for detection might possess just a small amount of heavy metals if
there exist since the water sample itself is quite small, which means there shall be very few residues on
that test paper. But if the user, usually some companies or factories, concentrate the sample to make the
concentration like 100 times, or more, before taking the detection, then the residue on the test paper
will be more, but still not accounted as much, you could dispose it off into the specific dustbin and the
hazardous waste treatment company to deal with it.
● Part 3.4 Digital visualization
Human eyes still have limitations when the changes in color are too mild to observe. But if you apply a digital processor to your detector, like a digital camera, linking to the cell phone system, like IOS, which could clearly catch the small changes of the color happening in the detection. Actually nowadays camera of a smartphone with 30,000,000 pixels is capable of calculating the value of the color, which means the digital camera could do the math for the quantitative analysis during detection. Actually, digital visualization on detection by smartphone is commonly used, for example, the customs staff’ smartphones have stored an app to scan those unknown packs. It might be not that accurate, and it does require more time and more money for development, but digital visualization on detection analysis has a promising future.
● Part 3.5 Government support and our future
Prof. Wen added, that the government is encouraging the development of this industry, and does introduce some policies to support it because it contributes to heavy metal pollution control, which classifies it as a strategic economic industry, but in fact, the current scale is very small. Now this kind of industry has to attach itself to some of the public institutions under the government so that it could share those policy advantages. It's a good industry, and it's very meaningful. But it's not an easy business.
Stakeholder Research
1. Qingyuan Huayan Waterworks
Since our research is about heavy metal detection, we went to a local waterworks (Suzhou Industrial Park Qingyuan Huayan Water Co., Lt) to learn the wastewater treatment process and figured out how heavy metals will be discharged by traditional process.
The manager tell us after the wastewater is collected by the drainage system, it enters the grating well of the wastewater treatment station to remove the particulate debris and then enters the regulating tank for homogenization and equalization, and the pre-aeration system is set in the regulating tank, and then the signal is transmitted by the liquid level controller and sent to the primary sedimentation tank by the lifting pump for precipitation. Biological contact oxidation tank for aerobic biochemical reaction, where most of the organic pollutants are degraded by biological oxidation and adsorption, and the effluent flows to the secondary sedimentation tank for solid-liquid separation.
In these processes, we find that each step has strict indicators to control the filtration of water quality, the residue of heavy metals through the microorganisms in the pool to filter and adjust, the very small probability will lead to the leakage of heavy metals, and in the final discharge process there will be a special person to carry out water sample sampling. It is clear that the product we have developed might not be suitable for large companies like waterworks, since we cannot analyze every specific component of the water sample and they don’t require quick detection. After this trip, we are more clear about the profile of our potential users who will be individual aqua culturists or normal families who have concerns about the drinking water and look for handy as well as a cheap detection method to avoid drinking heavy metal polluted water.
2. Jinke Environmental Ltd.
In order to have a better understanding of current solutions for wastewater processing, we managed to contact Jinke Water Engineering Co., Ltd through a phone call. Jinke focuses on providing membrane system solutions for water and sewage treatment, recycled water recycling, and seawater desalination, and is committed to using the company's proprietary technology and resources to purify water to any standard required by customers.
Below listed our phone interview conversations:
Q1: We understand that the main business of your company is to provide advanced water treatment. May I
ask which technology your company mainly utilizes to use to treat the wastewater? And why?
A: We use membrane treatment technology (physical method) which does not produce any additional chemicals
and is mainly for deep treatment (tertiary treatment). Of course, it still has weaknesses in that it has
difficulty dealing with those thick water.
Q2: Is water polluted by heavy metals included in your business? How does the treatment of heavy metal
polluted water differ from other sewage treatment methods?
A: It depends on the water quality of different places, according to different kinds of metal ions meant
to be removed to make different treatments.
Q3: What are your company's product positioning and target customers?
A: 1. Water companies
2. Industrial companies (semiconductors, electronics)
3. The relevant associations which target water pollution, water shortage, and water safety.
Q4: Do you know the government's policy and tax support for heavy metal detection products or such
companies?
A: Yes, like, taxes reduction (about 15%) and government subsidies. In addition, generally speaking, the
policy tends to improve the standard of drinking water and promote the development of the industry.
Q5: We know there will be a big leap from technology to product. May I ask how your company's products
landed? What are the main concerns or risks we need to consider or avoid?
A: In our company, take the example of the iron and manganese removal solution. We went through the whole
loop, including Developing a topic - developing a scheme - conducting a test - writing a report - applying
for a patent - small test/pilot test - application operation.
If it is not accepted by other companies, they will invest in it themselves and then apply it to the water
plant.
After communicating with Jinke, we learned about current methods to process wastewater but also realized that there is still many limitation and challenges which also proved that our product, a heavy metal detection biosensor is necessary for end users. In addition, we also learned from their experience in developing new technologies and landing the solution which will help us dress the future plans for sustainable development.
3. Zhanjiang Zhengda ENT Hospital
In addition to the wastewater from the chemical plants, we also noticed those medical waste which usually requires special treatment. Therefore, we managed to contact Zhanjiang Zhengda ENT Hospital and we had a phone call with the staff there who is responsible for the medical waste treatment.
Firstly the staff introduced the harm of medical waste if it is not well disposed of. Since he has worked in this position for a long time, based on his experience, the most commonly used method is to burn waste to dust. However, we all agreed that it is not eco-friendly. Therefore we further asked if it still has the risk of affecting the health of those who conduct the process. Although the answer wasn't that clear, he admitted that those staff will receive some allowance and the government will buy them medical insurance accordingly. He also added that they will have to conduct the medical waste process every 24 or 48 hours. All in all, we were very grateful for his sharing. Current waste process methods for medical waste still have risks of spreading pollution and those workers who work in the first line of waste treatment shall be of our target customers who are exposed to the pollution for a very long time.
4. Dye Factory (Suzhou Chuangyuan Chemical Co., Ltd.)
Based on our investigation from people around us, there is a common concern that dyes may contain heavy metals which means how well the dye factory treats its wastewater really matters. Therefore, we took a visit to a dye factory nearby, whose focus is on industrial oil paint, as well as chemical coatings.
The factory manager admitted that their products may have environmental impacts through different pathways: volatile organic compounds (VOC) components in their products may enter the atmosphere; methylbenzene and dimethylbenzene used may also be polluted into the environment.
When we asked them how these compounds were disposed of, it is said that now they strictly follow relevant regulations, and transfer their waste to professional water treatment plants to be treated. However, still, those water plants will treat their wastewater through normal procedures rather than designing special solutions to treat them differently. This could result in the accumulation of toxic components in the oil paint and coatings, and as it has been done for many years, could already be harmful to nearby residents.
According to the manager's sharing, we looked into the manufacturing process of their oil paint, and we have discovered that the production of their oil paint may result in contamination by heavy metals, especially during storage, where the solvent in the paint may interact with the metal storage barrels to take away those heavy metal ions.
This may not only pose a threat of long-term accumulation in the users of these oil paints, and workers in the factory but also potentially be leaked into their nearby river, posing threat to downstream residents. After a frank conversation with the manager of the dye factory, we realized that actually there are many potential risks to human health from the surroundings.
IHP to Experiments
- In our interview with Prof. Shan, who is an expert in environmental research we acknowledged that the need for heavy metal detection is strong for those individuals who are potentially exposed to heavy metal pollution that may accumulate slowly inside their bodies. Therefore, it is especially important to know the effective detection range, which can be done by using several samples containing different concentrations of Cadmium to measure.
-
In our interview with Dr. Li, who is familiar with the field of synthetic biology, he pointed out three
important things:
- There is no similar detection product in the market, so it can be an opportunity for us to break through a new way but also a challenge for us to start without enough case learning, especially no certain framework for product design.
- Since we probably will use heavy metal samples in our experiments for performance test, and it is important to dispose of anything potentially harmful produced during our experiments.
- Acellular systems can be a solution to avoid the safety concern caused by using live engineering bacteria.
- In our interview with Prof. Wen, we had a deeper understanding of the experimental design of biosensors and develop an experimental plan to make our final product functions quantitative.